Pond Pit BBQ Sandy Creek
Pond Pit BBQ Logo

Pond Pit BBQ

@

4.4735 reviews

Pond Pit BBQ is a must-visit for barbecue lovers. This true wood-fire BBQ spot serves delicious dishes and drinks. The ambiance is relaxed, perfect for friends and families. Located just off State Route 3 in Sandy Creek, it offers an outdoor terrace for sunny days.

The barbecue establishment boasts a bar open every day from 11 AM, with food available for dine-in or takeout. Known for its hearty portions, it is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The staff provides friendly service, despite the casual ordering system.

Enjoy a perfect meal with options from pulled pork sandwiches to gigantic plates like the Pig Pen. Prices are affordable, making it accessible for everyone. Guests can indulge in excellent cocktails while enjoying local music on select nights.

About

Pond Pit BBQ started as a passion project for barbecue enthusiasts. Inspired by the rich culture of BBQ in the region, it quickly became a local favorite. The establishment embraces traditional wood-fire cooking techniques, ensuring authentic flavors in every bite.

Set in Sandy Creek, a small town with a cozy vibe, Pond Pit BBQ perfectly fits the community. The open-air terrace enhances the laid-back atmosphere, allowing guests to enjoy their meals surrounded by nature. The BBQ experience here reflects both the essence of the town and the hearty cuisine.

The restaurant attracts a diverse crowd, including families, groups of friends, and travelers. Many visitors return, drawn by the inviting environment and signature BBQ dishes. The casual setting encourages mingling, adding to the local charm.

Get in Touch

8883 State Rte 3, Sandy Creek, NY 13145, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-19:00
  • Tuesday 11:00-19:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-17:00
  • Thursday 11:00-19:00
  • Friday 11:00-19:00
  • Saturday 11:00-19:00
  • Sunday 11:00-19:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Omg cannot wait to go back!!! It's about an hour from us but we will gladly make the drive again. Food was incredible! Great prices, great service, and food came out quick. We got the "Pig Pen" with Mac n cheese. Wonderful place, definitely check it out! :)"

- Sara C.

"This place checks all my boxes! Sage is an absolute SWEETHEART! I asked so many questions! The owner came out and shot the breeze between orders. Its a nice laid back spot that will not disappoint! I had the Huey hog w salt potatoes and mac n cheese. DELICIOUS! Do yourself a flavor and check them out!"

- Charles K.

"Best dang BBQ in upstate NY better than dinosaur and all. The sauces are amazing everything was top tier. I got one suggestion they should add a 3 way or 2 way platter so you can mix n match meats with sides."

- Anthony

"We finally made it up to Pond Pit BBQ in Sandy Creek. We shared the brisket nachos and the Pig Pen (basically a garbage plate). The nachos were awesome. Smothered in meat and sauces. The chips were super crispy. The Pig Pen was enormous. The lady at the order window even warned me about it. We also got the bigger one with mac n cheese added. Everything in that was good, but the standouts for me were the chicken and the mac n cheese. Despite our best efforts, we weren't able to conquer all of it, but we gave it the ol college try. Maybe the best thing about this place, though, is the drinks. I had a beer, she had two huge cocktails. $10 total for the drinks. As others have mentioned before, this place doesn't have traditional service. You seat yourself. Order/pay for food at the window. Order/pay for your drinks at the bar. If you find yourselves up in the area, give them a try. You won't be disappointed!"

- Kurt P.

"The food is good. I recommend take out because there is no real dining room & seating isn't the best. Also, the bands are too loud for the small space. IMPORTANT!! Call ahead because they constantly close WITHOUT NOTICE."

- Kel M.

"Food is amazing! We stopped on the way back from Grimshaw Farms. I had the Huey hog sandwich. My husband half a pig plate. We will be traveling the 45 minutes for bbq."

- Kelly D.

"Portions are generous. Corn bread crumbles but good. We both had the Pulled Pork. The Pork didn't have much of a smoke flavor. I did not like the slaw and I love slaw on Pulled Pork. We had the Red sauce, didn't like it. Having read more reviews, next time we would try Ribs or Brisket . The high top tables have barrels holding them up so you can't put your legs under them like a regular high top."

- Will S.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visitors must try the Pulled Pork sandwich, topped with tangy sauce and served with crispy salt potatoes. Another standout is the Pig Pen, a massive BBQ plate that combines multiple flavors. Satisfied diners rave about the brisquet and mac and cheese, perfect for sharing.

The atmosphere is relaxed, which enhances the dining experience. The bar offers great cocktails where patrons can unwind. The barbecue pit basks in a warm glow, adding to the inviting atmosphere. Live music nights are a hit and create a lively environment for dining.

Expect busy weekends, especially Saturdays. However, arriving early or visiting during off-peak hours ensures a more relaxed experience. Families appreciate the kid-friendly menu, making it a great spot for gatherings. Do not forget to call ahead to verify operating hours.

Most Liked things

Diners love the casual, laid-back atmosphere that encourages relaxation and enjoyment.

The delicious and generous portions of BBQ are often highlighted. Recommendations include the savory brisket and flavorful pulled pork sandwiches. Cocktails at the bar, paired with live music, create a fun experience. The friendly staff receive rave reviews, enhancing the overall vibe.

Outdoor seating options add a nice touch, perfect for gathering with friends on sunny days. Guests appreciate the accessible entries and amenities.

Most Disliked things

Some visitors find the dining area lacks traditional service. Seating can be limited during peak times, which some diners dislike, along with noise from live music events.

Occasionally, unexpected closures occur without prior notice, frustrating those who arrive ready to dine. The outdoor seating may not be suitable for everyone during colder months. While the venue is friendly for children, some suggest improving kid's menu options.

Lastly, the ordering process may take time for newbies, as it is not like traditional restaurant service.

FAQ

What are the bar hours at Pond Pit BBQ?

The bar opens daily at 11 am and remains open until 10 pm, providing a perfect spot for drinks after dinner.

What types of food menus does Pond Pit BBQ offer?

Pond Pit BBQ offers various menus, including starters, sandwiches, specialty burgers, sides, and more. Each menu bursts with flavor and BBQ specialties.

Are there vegetarian options available at Pond Pit BBQ?

Yes, Pond Pit BBQ features salads and some sides that cater to vegetarian diets. Options include the Chicken Caesar Salad and various side dishes.

Is Pond Pit BBQ pet-friendly?

While it's best to check directly, the outdoor terrace often accommodates pets. Outdoor seating can be a nice option for dining with pets.

Does Pond Pit BBQ provide takeout services?

Yes, takeout services are available at Pond Pit BBQ. You can order your favorite dishes and enjoy them wherever you prefer.